Not everyone is a good book reviewer. Those who are good follow some simple guidelines that serve to help readers select their next read.
- Usually, there’s a short summary. It’s best to avoid spoilers, but if you can’t avoid them, say so up front. That way, someone can decide whether or not to continue reading what you’ve written.
- If you liked the book, say so, and offer reasons why. If you didn’t like it, do the same and make it clear.
- Your review is your opinion, but if possible, try to present a balanced perspective.
- Don’t forget to proofread your copy before you post it.
Since you are probably an avid reader (many reviewers are), it might help to take notes on books that you intend to review. That will make it easier to recall your reading experience when it’s time to write your thoughts about the book.
Some notes that can be helpful are: quotes that strike you as memorable, as well as how you react to a particular character or scene or chapter. These kinds of details add interest and value to what you write.
If you have read other books that are similar in some way, add this information to your review.
If you’re a writer. You’re very familiar with the “hook.” Use one in your review to engage your reader and hopefully keep them reading.
Know who your readers will likely be and choose your language and tone keeping them in mind.
Once you’ve posted your review, it’s a good idea to check back and see if there is a reaction to it. It’s also a good idea to respond with comments. Reviews are another opportunity to build a network.
Do you review? Do you have any other ideas about how to be a “good reviewer”?
3 comments:
Thanks for a great article, Lee! I do review books, but I only review books I've read and liked. The retired elementary teacher in me tries to give positive criticism, if there is something that I am bothered with. Almost all the reviews I do are unsolicited. I'm pretty hard physically on books I think I may review, because I underline, write notes on blank pages and in the margins, and dog-ear pages. I like to review books written by IWSG members to support them. I need to work more on that "hook."
Proofreading your review is a good idea!
I never bash a book. If I can't give it three stars or more, I don't review it. And usually if I dislike it that much, I don't finish reading it, and I won't review a book I didn't finish either.
Although I've been writing reviews on my blog for 14 years, I still enjoyed reading the criteria you use. It gave me a fresh perspective on how to make the review its most effective. Thank you!
Post a Comment