I would like to introduce everyone to Alicia Dean, editor
for The Wild Rose Press under the name Ally Robertson. She is discussing
filtering out filter words to help us “show” not “tell”. This is a great lesson, and I hope you enjoy it.
Hello all…I’m happy to be joining the IWSG today, and I’m especially happy to share a little about revising/editing with
you. I love working with authors, and if my experience and limited knowledge
helps in any small way, I’m thrilled.
Working for The Wild Rose Press, I
receive many fantastic submissions, and of course, I receive many that are not
so fantastic. J Even out of
the well-written, stupendous, engaging manuscripts, I often find that sometimes
the authors lean a little heavily on filter words. These are ‘filter’ words
because they distance the reader from the action and from the character’s
emotion. Words like ‘felt,’ ‘thought,’ ‘wondered,’ ‘heard,’ ‘saw,’ ‘knew,’
‘noticed,’ etc. Avoiding words like these can make your writing much more
active. Filter words are also closely related to ‘telling’ vs ‘showing.’ If you
say your character felt or thought something, rather than just
‘showing’ the thought or emotion, then you are telling, when you could be
showing.
A few quick examples--and these are
taken from recent books I’ve read by extremely successful NYT
Best-Selling Authors. Of course, who am I to advise someone who’s done
exceedingly well without my advice? However, I couldn’t help but be a bit
jarred when I read lines like:
·
She felt panic race through her bloodstream
· How would she ever get him to talk? Maya
thought.
·
Maya saw him exit a door on the east side of
the building.
·
She knew Mark had been working there for four
years.
Just a few
brief tweaks would bring us much closer to what’s happening:
·
Panic raced through her bloodstream
·
How would she ever get him to talk? (We’re in
Maya’s point of view, and there were no dialogue tags, so readers know she
‘thought’ it)
·
He exited a door on the east side of the
building. (We’re in her POV, and if the author just states that he exited a
door, readers will know she ‘saw’ it happen)
·
Mark had been working there for four years.
(Again, readers know she ‘knew’ it because it was stated while in her POV)
I know it’s worse for me than an average
reader, since it’s my job to ‘edit,’ but whether or not a reader realizes that
the author is using filter words and telling instead of showing, they DO know
whether or not they can relate, and I believe they can relate more fully if we
try to avoid filter words that might distance them.
Having said that, I would definitely not
reject a manuscript because of overusage of filter words, but it is something
we would most assuredly work on during edits.
Do you have the nasty filter word habit?
You might just consider words like this as you’re revising, and see how many
you can eliminate to make your story more active. Even now, I read books I’ve
written and I find where I used filter words too. It’s easy to let them slip
in. Thank you for joining me today. If you have any questions, I’ll be happy to
answer them.
Check out Alicia's blog every Tuesday for her Two-Minute Tips where she offers quick tips for busy writers. https://aliciadean.com/alicias-blog/
Check out Alicia's blog every Tuesday for her Two-Minute Tips where she offers quick tips for busy writers. https://aliciadean.com/alicias-blog/
BIO:
Alicia Dean lives in Edmond, Oklahoma.
She has three grown children and a huge network of supportive friends and
family. She writes mostly contemporary suspense and paranormal, but has also
written in other genres, including a few vintage historicals.
In addition to being an author of more
than twenty-five published works, Alicia is both a freelance editor and an
editor for The Wild Rose Press, under the name, Ally Robertson, in their
suspense line.
Other than reading and writing, her
passions are Elvis Presley, MLB, NFL (she usually works in a mention of one or
all three into her stories) and watching her favorite televisions shows like
Vampire Diaries, Justified, Sons of Anarchy, Haven, The Mindy Project, and
Dexter (even though it has sadly ended, she will forever be a fan). Some of her
favorite authors are Michael Connelly, Dennis Lehane, Lee Child, Lisa Gardner,
Sharon Sala, Jordan Dane, Ridley Pearson, Joseph Finder, and Jonathan
Kellerman…to name a few.
Find Alicia Here:
*** Sign up for our Novel Notes Newsletter, a multi-author newsletter where we give away a $25 gift card each month: https://www.facebook.com/NovelNotesAuthors
24 comments:
Great examples on how to fix the problem. I know I leaned heavily on words like felt when I was a new author. I know to do a search and destroy for those suckers now.
I'm getting better at avoiding those in the first draft and catch most of them in the second. Very instructive post.
Oh yes feel/felt, see/saw/seen, think, try to name a few... I don't concern myself with them in the first draft, but I sure do go after them in subsequent drafts and revisions.
Thanks for being our guest today, Alicia. Those filter words were something I learned to cut early in my writing career. Sometimes they sneak into my first drafts, but I can edit them out later. Thanks for the advice!
Felt/feel I sure used to use a lot, less and less now. Still never as bad as just and seemed, cut those out altogether lol
Alicia, you have remarkable patience and your thoughtful tips certainly do resonate. Like Bish, first I write. Then I revise, review, refine and release to an editor who inevitably advises a 'little more' tweaking ;-) It's all worth it in the end!
Thanks for these all-important reminders, great post, Ladies :-)
Wonderful post and examples. I'm much better at filtering out those words than I use to be. It does make the writing so much tighter to eliminate them.
Great post and tips.
Juneta @ Writer's Gambit
Yes, those are nasty little buggers. They creep into my writing no matter how hard I try to avoid them. Often, I'm able to get rid of them during editing, but sometimes, they stay, because the rhythm of the sentence is better with them in.
Thank you, all. I'm sorry to just now be dropping in. I've had such a hectic day. Yes, those words can easily slip in. I definitely don't worry about them in the draft. During revisions is the best time to tighten and polish your story.
I appreciate all the kind words. I'm glad you guys already have that little problem licked. :) Yes, Olga, sometimes the rhythm is better with them. There are really no absolutes in writing advice...whatever works best to make your story the best it can be.
Thanks again!
Excellent post! One that I will share with the writers whose work I edit. I'm always after them to show, rather than tell.
Love,
Janie
Thank you, Janie. So glad you found it helpful. Yes, many authors can't quite grasp the showing/telling part of writing. This is only one aspect but it's one I see mishandled often. What floors me is how many successful authors do it frequently. I guess they can get by with it, but why would they want to? :)
Ah thank you for the reminder; this seems like a habit it would be so easy to fall into.
This is one of my flaws when writing. This over-explaining when there isn't any need to write most of it can be a terrible habit. I'm getting so I see myself do it and immediately start pounding on the backspace key.
Ugh, I dislike reading a book that has too many of those, and I usually find them mostly in first POV. I do try to weed them out during my editing/revision phase.
Sometimes, my fingers type those filters without my conscious thought. Gotta go with the moment- during first draft.
Hi Chrys - thanks for introducing us to Alicia. Interesting examples and even thought I 'only' blog - and thus am not as thorough in editing as I should be - I realise there are phrases that are unnecessary and add to word clutter - thanks .. wonderful post - cheers Hilary
I was aware of these words. I do think they show up in my work occasionally, but I will be more vigilant now.
It is funny on how many of the things authors are not "supposed" to do end up in books on the best sellers lists.
James, yes, it's a very easy habit to fall into. I definitely do it often.
Ascripted, I see a lot of over-explaining in manuscripts, sometimes in my own. We have to realize readers are not stupid, they'll get what you're trying to convey :)
Dolorah, I know, it drives me nuts! I agree, first draft, just spew it out, no matter how it's worded.
Hilary- Glad it was helpful!
Tamara - So true, the best sellers get by with a lot of no-no's. For me, it's not even about rules, it's about making your writing tighter and bringing readers closer to the emotion and action. When I read books, even from the big authors, with phrases like: 'She felt her heart swell with pride.' It's just irritating, because it's unnecessary and distant. We're being TOLD what she felt instead of just: Her heart swelled with pride. Sigh... :)
Thanks to all for stopping by!
Thanks for guest-hosting, Alicia. Your example are spot on. We can get lazy sometimes, so having a good editor point out some telling spots is a welcome part of the process. Thanks for all you do.
I really love, love, love seeing posts like this because it puts things in perspective and make so much sense. Kudos and HUGE Hugs...RO
I like reading such articles because I want to become a writer some day :) I'd like to write now, but I'm still a student, that's why sometimes I use http://www.essaywriters.reviews/ to help me with some tasks because I don't have enough time to do everything.
The more I edit, the more I notice these. "Writing" tips are also great resources/reminders for editors. Thanks!
With each new editorial or writing craft article/book/podcast I absorb, I become more aware of the way I write. I didn't even know I had a particular 'way', but it's not all stuff that needs changing! Thank you for the tips, something new to add to my editing checklist.
Great post!
I think we all have filter words that slip into our writing. Thank goodness for edits/revisions which take care of those critters.
Post a Comment